Skip to main content

Are Seminaries “Selling Their Souls”?

Brett Younger, associate professor of preaching at Mercer University’s McAfee School of Theology in Atlanta, is one of the best writers in Baptist life today.  He is at his best when writing satirical, humorous columns on the church and its various foibles.  I don’t think his recent post entitled “Seminaries reluctantly selling their souls” was meant to be humorous, however.  If it was, just disregard the rest of this blog.

Dr. Younger eloquently presents an argument for traditional, “residential” theological education.  This is the type of model that many of us experienced as we prepared for ministry.  We packed up all our earthly belongings, moved to another part of the country, and spent three years preparing for our first call.  If we were fortunate, we found a part-time church to supplement our income and give us some experience.  As seminary came to an end, we put out our resumes, started working our networks, and prayed fervently that God would lead us to the place where we would invest our lives and our newly developed skills.

I will grant that this model will still work for many students pursuing preparation for ministry, but much has changed.

First, when I attended seminary, my denomination invested a great deal in the cost of my education.  I left seminary with no debt.  Even so, when I was called to my first place of ministry and received a generous compensation package, our family was making less than we did when we were in seminary.  One significant reason was that my wife no longer worked and became a full-time mother for several years, so we went from a situation where she taught school, I had a part time job and a GI Bill benefits, and we lived in inexpensive seminary housing to the real world.  If we had accumulated significant seminary debt, I don’t know how we could have paid for it.

One change from then to now is that denominations and churches are not as invested in theological education as they once were.  Even seminaries with substantial endowments have to address the rising cost of personnel and maintenance on aging buildings.

Second, the demographics of ministry calling have changed.  The typical seminary student is older.  He or she responded to the call to ministry after several years in another vocation and a number of years of service to the church.  There are still students coming right out of college into seminary, but most recent graduates are still discerning what they will do with their lives. 

As a result, those called to ministry tend to be more established in their communities, have homes and families, and are already leaders (volunteer, part-time, or full-time) in a congregation, so the idea of relocating is not particularly attractive or feasible.

Third, although I valued the relationships I developed in seminary, I was often in classes with up to one hundred students.  Only in elective classes in certain subjects was I involved with only twenty or thirty students.  The context was very favorable for those who wanted to sit in the back of the room and be disengaged.  I made a number of friends in seminary and continued contact with them after graduation, but this became increasingly difficult since we scattered widely after we left seminary.  I was fortunate to establish relationships with several very fine professors, but this was the exception not the rule.

My friend David May, professor of New Testament at Central Baptist Theological Seminary, often points to studies that show that students in online education are often more engaged in discussions that students in face to face classrooms.  Their participation can be tracked, and they often feel more comfortable sharing their input through chat rooms and forums.  Their education becomes more interactive and personal.

Does this mean that the approach to theological education that Dr. Younger espouses is dead? Of course not. We need institutions like the one where he teaches to form students who choose that approach to ministerial formation.  They are essential to the growth of the body of Christ.  The reality is, however, that the size of this group is declining.

Does this mean that institutions that are offering other approaches have “sold their souls”?  No.  A recent study done by the Association of Theological Schools stated:  “When asked about areas of personal growth . . . graduates who had completed most or all of their work online rated their personal growth in several areas slightly higher than graduates who had completed most of their work on campus.”

Online education is just one of the alternatives available to theological students today. There are hybrid programs that provide both on-site and online training as well as partnerships with churches and other institutions.  All fill a need. 

I applaud the work that Dr. Younger is doing in a traditional setting (although I wonder if it as traditional as he states), but I also recognize there are options out there for students who want and need them.  The body of Christ is rich and diverse, so we should expect the same diversity in formation for ministry.


(For further information on the points above, take a look at the State of the [Theological Education] Industry presentation from the Association of Theological Schools.)




Comments

Mark Tidsworth said…
Excellent article. Insightful. Often those on the inside are so caught up in running the institution, it feels threatening to think creatively. Thank you for maintaining your objectivity, thinking outside the box, and watching for the Spirit winds even while serving through the institution.
Unknown said…
I appreciate your article Ircel. Having gone through seminary in the late 70's way before online education was even an idea, I have always contended the way I did it was the best But with the high cost of maintaining a campus and the heavy load of debt carried by most seminary graduates today, and with smaller and smaller first pastorates, many unable to pay the cost of a a salary let alone increasing benefit costs like insurance is it any wonder seminary grads enter the workforce with a debt load which will follow them the rest of their lives.
I appreciate hearing the remarks of Dr. May saying students participate more online, as one who was reluctant to raise their hand in class I feel that I would have been more comfortable to ask a question online rather than in front of my peers. The thing I would have missed the most being online would have been the interaction with other students in the student lounge where we talked about classes and readings as well as getting to know each other on a personal level.
As someone that did their MDiv at a seminary that had seen its students change from predominantly a full-time residential to predominantly part-time commuter student body, the need for diverse methods being available to train future church leaders is important. I was able to take about 20% of my credits via on-line courses and felt that the overall engagement in discussions was greater than in the traditional classroom, in part due to the structure of the on-line classes. In those classes in order to pass, one had to engage with the professor and other students, whereas in the classroom, the discussions were often dominated by a few students, and others could sit back. I also see that as the church in general is going through a time of change and transition, so too, must our seminaries, if they are to truly train up leaders for what God is doing with the church, then they can't be locked in on the way it has always been done.

Check these out

Confessions of a Recovering Southern Baptist

I am grateful for my heritage as a Southern Baptist.  I was exposed to the Bible and worship from a very young age.  I grew up in a church in south Alabama that supported the Cooperative Program of missions giving.  This meant that our church had the benefit of being part of a supportive group of local churches and the educational opportunities that afforded. Our state convention provided varied and effective ministries with groups like orphans, ethnic groups, and college students.  We supported missionaries at home and abroad.  We had good Bible study and training literature (which we paid for, of course).  I went to an accredited seminary and paid a remarkably low tuition.  Wherever you went on a Sunday morning (in the Southeast and Southwest, at least), you could find a church that sang the familiar hymns and studied the same Bible lesson. In hindsight, I realize that this Southern Baptist utopia was imperfect.  There were significant theological differences, often geograp

The Bible Tells Me So

As I read the story of the Good Samaritan during my devotional today, I was reminded of the times that I have heard the story in the Christian education setting of the local church--as a youngster in primary and intermediate classes (old terminology), as a young adult in college classes, and then as an adult, often teaching the passage myself.     The characters and story line are very familiar due to these experiences of Christian education. These are challenging times for Christian education in the church.  Like so much of what is happening in the church today, the old forms do not seem to support present needs.  What once worked no longer seems to be effective.  Christian education or the formation of believers is in a state of flux. In an article on ethicsdaily.com , retired professor Colin Harris addresses this issue. He points out that the period of the 60’s and 70’s  “saw the beginnings of a loss of vitality within the educational dimension of church ministry, as the

A Future for the Global Leadership Summit?

Craig Groeschel, the founder and senior pastor of Life.Church. The Global Leadership Summit which began as a project of Willow Creek Community Church in South Barrington, Illinois, and its founding pastor, Bill Hybels, over 25 years ago was held this week without Hybels. For several years, the GLS has been now produced by the Willow Creek Association, a spin-off organization and a loose network of churches but Hybels has been its driving force. Attended by thousands at the church facility in South Barrington and broadcast to thousands more at satellite locations, the annual meeting brings together not only evangelical leaders but outstanding speakers from business, charitable organizations, politics, and business.  For the first time, Hybels did not appear due to allegations of sexual impropriety brought against him over the past year by former employees, staff members, and business associates.  He has already left the church and resigned from the board of the association.

The Baptist Diaspora

I have just returned from the Cooperative Baptist Fellowship General Assembly.   As usual, I had the opportunity to meet and greet many friends and colleagues.   My reflections on the meeting will wait until tomorrow, but as I drove home and thought about who I had seen there, I also thought about those who were not there. During the 1980s and 1990s, the progressive Baptist movement in the south lost many who had identified with the Southern Baptist Convention to other denominations.  Women ministers moved to denominations such as United Methodists to become pastors.  Some changed to denominations such as the United Church of Christ due to its clear stance on issues of social justice. Others became Episcopalians because of their love of the liturgy. The exodus continues today, however.  An American Baptist friend on the west coast told me recently that several young ministers who had been nurtured in CBF churches and seminaries had accepted churches in his a

Calling a Woman as Pastor

From time to time, I receive a call from a member of a pastor search committee that is considering a woman as their senior pastor (which is a term that I don’t find anywhere in scripture, but I understand the concept).   I am always flattered that the candidate has chosen to use me as a reference, so I take the opportunity very seriously.   I must admit, however, that I come out of some of those conversations a bit frustrated. The interviewer usually has a set series of questions, and I try to respond appropriately while pushing the boundaries a bit.   By doing so, I am often able to engage the interviewer more informally and address some concerns specifically related to women in a pastoral role.   As a result, I am no longer surprised when the caller will say something to the effect, “But there are some on our committee who feel that she does not have enough experience.”    On one hand, if the concern is that the candidate does not have any experience as a senior pastor